7 Comments
User's avatar
Wahidullah Noorzai | NIDA's avatar

An important dimension of great-power rivalry is often overlooked: the strategic autonomy of states situated within competing geopolitical environments.

The competition between the United States and China is not simply about influence over regional actors; it is also about how countries such as Pakistan and Afghanistan preserve their freedom of action, national interests and long-term strategic options.

Geographical importance does not automatically translate into strategic advantage. Without institutional strength, economic resilience and informed political judgment, even strategically positioned states can become increasingly dependent on external powers.

Afghanistan's experience offers an important lesson: external influence and military superiority cannot, by themselves, produce sustainable security or a durable political order.

The deeper strategic question is therefore not which great power gains greater influence, but whether regional states can develop the internal capacity to shape their own future rather than remain instruments of competing external interests.

Great-power rivalry determines the pressures of the international environment; strategic autonomy determines how regional states respond to them.

— Wahidullah Noorzai | NIDA

Glodi  Ntoya's avatar

An interesting argument, but I would argue that strategic autonomy should not be understood solely through the strength of domestic institutions or economic resilience.

For countries such as Pakistan and Afghanistan, geography, security dependencies and the realities of the international system significantly shape the choices available to them. Strategic autonomy is not necessarily about reducing external influence, but about managing competing external interests without allowing any single power to dictate national priorities.

In an increasingly multipolar world, the ability to diversify partnerships, negotiate competing interests and maintain diplomatic flexibility may be just as important as internal institutional strength.

Perhaps the real question is not whether states can escape great-power competition, but whether they can turn that competition into strategic leverage.

Wahidullah Noorzai | NIDA's avatar

I have also explored this question in a published piece, approaching it through field-informed strategic analysis. My argument draws on Afghanistan’s experience to examine how geography, great-power competition and external dependencies interact with domestic institutional capacity and national freedom of action. I believe this perspective adds an important practical dimension to the broader theoretical debate.

Glodi  Ntoya's avatar

That's an interesting perspective, and I'd be keen to read your published piece. I think Afghanistan provides an important practical case study of how external influence, geography and domestic capacity interact.

My broader point is that strategic autonomy also requires us to examine how states can actively navigate great-power competition. Rather than viewing external relationships purely through the lens of dependency, I think we should also consider how countries can diversify partnerships, balance competing interests and turn geopolitical competition into diplomatic leverage.

It would be interesting to explore where domestic institutional strength ends and strategic diplomatic flexibility begins.

Wahidullah Noorzai | NIDA's avatar

Thank you for your thoughtful response. I appreciate your perspective, particularly your emphasis on how states can actively navigate great-power competition rather than simply remain subject to external pressures.

I have written on these questions on several occasions, drawing on Afghanistan's experience and the wider regional environment. I agree that diversifying partnerships, balancing competing interests and converting geopolitical competition into diplomatic leverage are important dimensions of strategic autonomy.

However, I would emphasise that diplomatic flexibility can only produce sustainable strategic advantages when supported by sufficient domestic institutional, economic and political capacity. Without that foundation, diversification may simply replace one form of dependency with another.

I have explored these interconnected issues in my recent article:

Beyond Great-Power Rivalry: Strategic Autonomy, Regional Power and the Future of South Asia

https://noozai.substack.com/p/beyond-great-power-rivalry-strategic

The article examines Pakistan and Afghanistan as distinct but interconnected cases, while developing a broader field-informed perspective on the relationship between geographical position, external influence, domestic capacity and strategic freedom of action.

I would genuinely welcome your thoughts after reading it. In particular, your question about where institutional strength ends and strategic diplomatic flexibility begins is worth examining further. In my view, these are not competing dimensions; they are mutually reinforcing foundations of sustainable strategic autonomy.

Best regards,

Wahidullah Noorzai